thanksgiving
All pies are 10”
Apple Crumb
Classic Apple
Vegan Apple
Brown Butter Pecan
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
Mixed Berry
Pumpkin
Sweet Potato
Sweet Potato Pecan
Frequently Asked Thanksgiving Questions
What pies are on the Thanksgiving menu?
How can I get a pie for my Thanksgiving holiday?
Three ways:
Come down to the bakery on Tuesday 11/25 & Wednesday 11/26 for a freshly baked pie.
Visit select local farm stands and specialty stores in Greater Boston that carry a selection of our pies. (keep scrolling)
Stop by before November 22nd to see what’s available for Take ‘n Bake or Take ’n Thaw pies for purchase and pickup before Thanksgiving week.
In shop
You can stop by the shop at 285 Beacon Street. Shop hours Thanksgiving week:
Tuesday, 10am - 6pm and Wednesday, 8am until sold out. There will be no pie pre-ordering for Thanksgiving. Instead, like any other day, customers can stop by on Tuesday or Wednesday during the week of Thanksgiving and pick from the freshest pies on the shelf.
The last pre-order for pies in November will be taken on Thursday, November 20, for pick up on Friday, November 21. Online pre-orders will begin again on December 2nd.
Pie Around Town
We partner with many local farm stands and specialty stores in Greater Boston to bring pies closer to you. See below to see if there is a local business selling Petsi Pies near you during the Thanksgiving holiday. Some may take pre-orders!
Allandale Farm, Brookline
City Feed, Jamaica Plain
Volante Farms, Needham
Mahoney’s, Winchester
D’Agostino’s, Arlington
Black Sheep Market, Cambridge
D’Agostino’s, Winchester
Crescent Ridge Dairy
Walden Local Meat offers its members apple and pecan pies w holiday share order.
Shubie’s, Marblehead
Fruit Center Marketplace, Milton & Hingham
Idylwilde Farm, Acton
North of Boston: farm & food hub, Boxford
Nouvelle Maison, Winchester
Yes, hours of operation vary. While there is no pre-ordering of pies for pickup Thanksgiving week, we will have regular hours and online ordering available through Thursday, November 20, for pickup by Friday, November 21. We will be open Saturday, November 22, from 9am to 3pm for walk-in sales only. (We do NOT recommend buying or freezing pies on this day to eat 5 days later).
Additionally, the bakery is open for walk-in sales only on Tuesday, November 25, from 10am to 6pm and Wednesday, November 26, from 8am ‘til sold out.
Are the hours and online ordering different for the month of November?
November 1st-22nd
Monday-Friday 8am-5pm, Saturday & Sunday 9am-3pm
November 23rd & 24th CLOSED
November 25th 10am-6pm
November 26th 8am- ’til sold out!
November 27th-December 1st CLOSED
What are the store hours for Petsi Pies in November?
We're not here to tell you that there won't be a line when you roll up—it is the week before Thanksgiving, after all. But that line will move quickly: there will be multiple checkout stations and a board listing available pies. You will choose your pies, pay by cash or credit card, and return home in a [relative] flash. There will only be 10” pies available from the Thanksgiving menu. We will not have any pastries or beverages available for sale.
What can I expect when I come to the shop Tuesday and Wednesday before Thanksgiving?
This is a possibility. So, we suggest you have first and second choices so that you won’t be disappointed. Without getting too deep into pie making, we rotate the type of pies baked at any given time, so there will be a rolling cycle of every type every day. It’s just a matter of who buys what and when. Just like any store, really.
What if the pie flavors I want to purchase aren’t available when I stop by?
Is there parking available for Tuesday and Wednesday pickup hours at the bakery?
There is street parking all along one side of Beacon Street. Star Market will tow cars parked longer than a few minutes.
Petsi Pies is closed for the Thanksgiving holiday weekend (Thursday, November 28 – Monday, December 2) to give our staff much-needed rest and time with family. However, we reopen for regular business on Tuesday, December 3, at 8:00 am. We look forward to seeing you!
What are the shop hours for Thanksgiving weekend?
What if I want to order a large number of pies the week before Thanksgiving?
We appreciate your enthusiasm, but large orders (more than 20) are typically taken in October to manage supplies and staffing. Email us at catering@petsipies.com to inquire.
